The only thing that I like more than gifting cookies is a theme and this year, the theme of my Christmas cookie box is... The Nutcracker! An entire cookie box based on a nostalgic, holiday classic. Some of the cookies are inspired by the ballet, and some by E.T.A. Hoffman. I found that having a theme actually made it easier to decide which cookies and flavors to bake. It also makes the cookie box more interesting to design and receive.
I learned a lot from last year's cookie box. The first thing was to space out my baking so that I don't end up baking past midnight! I spaced it out over the span of four days in order to only bake a few hours a day. All of these cookies can be made and frozen (in freezer bags in advance!!!) It made it much more manageable, enjoyable, and I highly recommend doing this. So I guess you could say that I finally learned to manage my cookie baking time this year. Hooray!
I'm so excited to share my cookie lineup with you this year. They all turned out so cute and there's a very good assortment of flavors, textures, and classic holiday flavors while staying true to the Nutcracker theme. Here is the cookie lineup, going clockwise starting from the gingerbread nutcracker cookies:
- Gingerbread nutcracker cookies
- Soft (lofthouse style) snowflake sugar cookies frosted with buttercream
- Piped pink bow cookies
- Christmas tree caramel sugar cookies
- Walnut cookies (Oreshki)
- Chocolate raspberry thumbprint cookies
- Sugar plum cookies
- Christmas mice snowball cookies
Jump to:
- 🍪 How to choose cookies and boxes
- 🥜 Gingerbread Nutcracker Cookies
- ❄ Soft Snowflake Sugar Cookies (Lofthouse Style)
- 🎀 Piped Butter Bow Cookies
- 🎄 Christmas Tree Caramel Sugar Cookies
- 🥜 Walnut Cookies Oreshki
- 🎁 Christmas Chocolate Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies
- 🧚♂️ Sugar Plum Cookies
- 🐭 Christmas Mice Cookies
- 🎄 More Christmas and holiday cookie box recipes
- 💬 Comments
🍪 How to choose cookies and boxes
For cookie boxes, I try to choose cookies that don't require refrigeration or could go a while without refrigerating. Plus, the cookies that I make must be easy to make with low fuss decorations! I also try to get a variety of flavors to make the cookie box more interesting when eating and prevent repeating flavors.
I find that metal cookie tins from the dollar store (or upcycled from previous years/chocolates) make for the best cookie boxes because they seal really well and the cookies stay fresh inside for longer. However, my stash of cookie boxes got lost somewhere during my move. So this year, I decided to package the cookies in cake boxes. It worked really well and it was actually easier to package the cookies into larger boxes.
Pro Cookie Box Tip: Don't forget to wash the tins and line them with parchment or wax paper. If you use cardboard boxes - make sure you line them as well so that the cookies don't taste like cardboard.
🥜 Gingerbread Nutcracker Cookies
I don't feel like a holiday cookie box is complete without a spiced gingerbread cookie. Last year I included my jam filled thick molded gingerbread cookies. This year, I found a nutcracker cookie cutter at my local craft store and thought that gingerbread nutcracker cookies would be so cute all lined up! Their spiced, deep molasses flavor fits the masculine vibe of the cookies. Also, they're easy and fun to decorate with just white icing. Simple, elegant, festive, and so delicious. You do need to chill the dough but it results in the most perfectly soft and chewy gingerbread cookies so it is well worth it.
❄ Soft Snowflake Sugar Cookies (Lofthouse Style)
These snowflake cookies were inspired by the iconic snowflakes in the Nutcracker ballet and are my personal favorite. Unfortunately not as many made it into the boxes as I had hoped because I did end up "taste testing" too many. I finally nailed that soft and fluffy lofthouse cookie texture and intense vanilla cake flavor. Thick cut, layered with thick airy buttercream; these are a crowd pleaser. I kept the decorations simple with a layer of buttercream, sparkling sugar or nonpariel sprinkles, and an easy piped snowflake.
🎀 Piped Butter Bow Cookies
I had almost given up on this recipe during the developing stage. I had already made these piped butter cookies 7 times and they were either spreading into a puddle, had weird craggly edges, impossible to pipe, or just gummy inside. I slept on the recipe and woke up the next day with the corrections to create the perfect piped butter cookies. They're crisp, buttery, and with all my tips and tricks - foolproof!
Piped butter cookies are a classic addition to Christmas cookie boxes and these pink bows are a nod to the iconic bow that Clara wears in her head in the Nutcracker.
🎄 Christmas Tree Caramel Sugar Cookies
To tie the Christmas theme together, I felt like the cookie box was missing a classic festive sugar cookie. So I went with these cut out soft and chewy, no chill, caramel sugar cookies. They're easy to decorate in royal icing (just dip and sprinkle). Homemade toffee bits gives these cookies loads of salted caramel flavor without affecting their spread!
🥜 Walnut Cookies Oreshki
These walnut shaped cookies are an Eastern European classic, aligning perfectly with the Nutcracker and Russian ballet theme. They're crunchy wafer cookies filled with dulce de leche. Some people will also add a toasted nut inside but I couldn't find my walnuts. They're cooked on the stovetop in a waffle-like mold and are effortlessly delicious. The cookie dough is easy to make and required no chilling. The caramel dulce de leche filling is so creamy, festive, and flavorful. These walnut cookies are the perfect stable and sturdy cookie for cookie boxes.
🎁 Christmas Chocolate Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies
If you read last year's cookie box post, you'd know that this is a repeat cookie from last year. But I couldn't help including them! They were the most popular cookie last year and this cookie box was lacking a soft chocolate cookie. Thumbprint cookies are a holiday classic! Plus, my recipe doesn't require chilling and is easy to make and soooo delicious.
I added cocoa powder into all of the cookie dough, double what the recipe recommends since it isn't added to just half of the dough. I used my finger to create heart shaped indents for the jam. I went with raspberry jam since chocolate and raspberry are one of my favorite flavor combinations.
🧚♂️ Sugar Plum Cookies
The Sugar Plum Fairy is quite probably one of the most popular Nutcracker characters, so I had to include cute little sugared plums! They're soft, olive oil cookies filled with a fragrant spiced plum jam. They're elevated, delicious, and one of the more popular cookies in the Nutcracker cookie boxes.
🐭 Christmas Mice Cookies
Christmas is not complete without Christmas mice! Mice have an important role in The Nutcracker too. I shaped delicious, buttery snowball cookies into mice with almond ears to create these fluffy adorable mice. Lightly toasted pecans add a beautiful festive toasty flavor. You don't need to chill these cookies and they're quite easy to make. The powdered sugar coating melts in your mouth like a classic holiday snowball cookie.
Did you make these recipes?
Share your creation on Instagram and tag @flouringkitchen. Follow me on Pinterest to save and for more recipe ideas.
Comments
No Comments